Resolved: The United States federal government should substantially increase its public health assistance to Sub-Saharan Africa.

     // home > tournaments > 2004-2005 Tournament 1

Photos
Evidence Center
Tips and Tactics
Participant Info Form
Forum

Team Registration
Case Disclosure Form 
Debate Games
CA Feedback

Sign Up Form
Round Description
Judging Tips
Training Sessions

Calendar
Results

Coaching-Assistants
Teacher-Coaches

Contact Us
Participating Schools
National UDL Links

2004 Tournament 1
HSTA, October 30 2004. Divisions: Varsity, Novice

Varsity

First Place Team: PAIS FF - Elsie Fernandez and Elizabeth Frias
Second Place Team: Classical DM - Randell Dauda and Cindy Mit
Third Place Team: Woonsocket AG - Justin Alvarez and Charles Grenier
Fourth Place Team: Classical MM - Nina Mazel and Miguel Miranda

First Place Speaker: Elsie Fernandez - PAIS
Second Place Speaker: Charles Grenier - Woonsocket
Third Place Speaker: Nina Mazel - Classical
Fourth Place Speaker: Elizabeth Frias - PAIS

Team Records

Team Round 1 Round 2 Round 3 Total Speaker Points
Classical MM Loss Loss Win 163.5
Classical MD Win Win Win 159.6
MET DS Win Loss Loss 157
Mount Pleasant LP Loss Loss Loss 158
PAIS FF Win Win Win 166
PAIS SM Loss Win Loss 160
Woonsocket NM Loss Loss Win 161
Woonsocket GA Win Win Loss 164.5

Speaker Points

Speaker Round 1 Round 2 Round 3 Total Speaker Points
Cindy Mit 26 28 25.5 79.5
Randell Dauda 27 28 25 80
Miguel Miranda 26 26.5 28 80.5
Nina Mazel 29 27 27 83
Elsie Fernandez 28 28 28.5 84.5
Elizabeth Frias 27 26.5 28 81.5
Luis Sanchez 26 28 26 80
Padraig Mahoney 27 27 26 80
Melissa Nespolo 26 27 27 80
Kerri Morrow 27 27 27 81
Charles Grenier 28.5 29 26.5

84

Justin Alvarez 27 28.5 25 80.5
Jonathan Delacruz 26 26 24 76
Loupu Stevens 25 27 28 80
Joshua Lopez 27 27 27 81
Rafael Pajaro 27 0 27 54

 

Novice

First Place Team: Woonsocket RS - Melissa Ryan and Cindy Sou
Second Place Team: Mount Pleasant CM - Jaime Cadet and Guerlin Milord
Third Place Team: Woonsocket SL - Leandra Salia and Fallon Lalliberte
Fourth Place Team: Woonsocket SD - Amy Durand and Natasha Scully

First Place Speaker: Cindy Sou - Woonsocket
Second Place Speaker: Guerlin Milord - Mount Pleasant
Third Place Speaker: Jaime Cadet - Mount Pleasant
Fourth Place Speaker: Melissa Ryan - Woonsocket

Team Records

Team Round 1 Round 2 Round 3 Total Speaker Points
Classical SS Win Loss Loss 155.5
Feinstein MP Loss Loss Win 154
PAIS/Feinstein NJL Loss Loss Win 156
HSTA NM Loss Win Loss 156
HSTA JJ Loss Loss Win 153
HSTA DB Loss Loss Win 151
MET RW Loss Loss Loss 152
MET MS Loss Win Loss

159

Mount Pleasant CM Win Win Win 158
Woonsocket SL Win Win Win 159.5
Woonsocket RS Win Win Win

170

Woonsocket EM Win Win Loss 160
Woonsocket SFJ Win Loss Win 163.5
Woonsocket SD Win Win Loss 164
Woonsocket DK Win Win Loss 163

Speaker Points

Speaker Round 1 Round 2 Round 3 Total Speaker Points
Hector Soltman 25 25.5 27.5 78
Friedrich Nietzsche 25 25 27.5 77.5
Jaime Cadet 28 28 28 84
Guerline Milord 28 29 28 85
Jose Nunez 26 27 25 78
Valentina Jean-Claude 27 26 25 78
Illiana Delgado 25 25 25 75
Claudia Borilla 26 25 25 76
Jerimiah Joseph 26 26 25 77
Malcolm Taylor 26 25 25 76
Yesseria Nunez 27 26 26

79

Kevin Matta 25 27 25 77
Laura Murphy 28 28 25 78
Ally Scola 26 27 25 78
Anabel Reyes 0 0 0 0
Jordan Walker 26 25 25 76
Essy Asgarian 27 25 28 80
Aicha Ly 27 25 28 80
Melissa Ryan 28 27 28 83
Cindy Sou 29 28 30 87
Courtney Dwyer 27 26 28 81
Preeti Kinha 27 27 28 82
Natasha Scully 28 28 27 83
Amy Durand 28 26 27 81
Rodeline Saint Felix 27 26 27.5 80.5
Stephanie Jorge 27.5 28 27.5 83
Leandra Salie 27.5 26 27 80.5
Fallon Lalliberte 27 26 26 79
Natasha Marshall 25 26 25 76
Masiel Perez 25 26 27 78

The Rhode Island Urban Debate League is a partnership between the Swearer Center for Public Service at Brown University
and the public schools of Rhode Island.

Rhode Island Urban Debate League (C) 2004-2007
p. 401.863.9836  :  f. 401.863.3094  :  e. ridl@brown.edu  :  Webmaster: Shiyin Wang